21 Feb 2025

The Jungle Book vs. The Lion King – No Contest

by | posted in: Movie, Review | 65

Here it is, folks, the movie review you’ve been waiting for since 1994 when The Lion King first appeared.  It was inevitable that someone would eventually compare it with The Jungle Book, a classic Disney film from 1967.  For those of you who haven’t made the leap yet, both The Jungle Book (1967) and The Lion King are both coming-of-age tales, that is, both movies attempt to present the growth and maturation of two males of their species, Mowgli the Man Cub and Simba the Lion King.

The Jungle Book vs. The Lion KIng - No Contest! #robertglover #movie #moviereview Share on X

Although both movies attempt to show the two characters coming of age, only one succeeds.  The other fails completely.  Can you guess which?

Jungle Book: Baloo, Mowgli, and Bagheera
Baloo, Mowgli, and Bagheera

Why Now?

“Why now?” is a good question.  Is it that I have a thirteen-year-old daughter in the prime of her animated movie existence, her cartoon wheelhouse, and having watched every Disney film a dozen times or more – thanks, streaming – she has a sharp eye for the nuances of story development?  Or Is it my perennial adolescence, my own perpetual immaturity that prompted me to examine these two stories?

Either way, it’s an analysis that is long overdue.  The demand from blog-readers everywhere has been overwhelming.  That’s one of the reasons I post so infrequently now: I’m inundated with fan mail begging for this comparison.  The only topics close to this are my definitive ranking of chocolate chip cookies and my exposé of nut butters.

Before I get started, let me be up front.  Without a doubt, hands down, no questions asked, my favorite Disney movie of all time is The Jungle Book.  I love everything about it: the artwork, the story, the characters, but especially the music.  How do you beat vintage Louie Prima singing “I Wanna’ Be Like You”?  You can’t.  There’s no way.  Add in Phil Harris singing “The Bare Necessities” and you can’t miss.

Putting my jungle bias aside, here’s the real reason why The Jungle Book is a better movie than The Lion King…

Coming-of-Age

Both movies are coming-of-age tales, that is, they depict both characters, Mowgli and Simba, on their journey from cubs, man-cub in Mowgli’s case, to adults, and even in Simba’s case, to the King of the Jungle.  Mowgli never ascends to regal heights, so we should by rights, judge Simba’s journey more harshly.  After all, shouldn’t the king’s journey be more challenging than a simple villager?

It should, but despite that I’ll apply the same standard to both: is the character arc believable?  Do I believe that Mowgli has grown and he’s ready for the next phase of his life, a simple villager?  Do I believe that Simba has done enough to earn the right to be king?  What obstacles do they overcome that make me believe that they have grown and matured and are ready for the next step?

The Jungle Book

Mowgli has it tough from the beginning.  Orphaned in the jungle, Bagheera the panther finds him and instead of devouring him for breakfast – Baghee must have feasted recently on a chinkara – he transports him to a family of wolves to raise.  This is all right for a while, but when news arrives that Shere Khan the tiger is in the vicinity and has sworn to kill Mowgli, the wolf pack meets at Council Rock and decides Mowgli must go back to his own people.

Bagheera volunteers to guide him to the Man-Village and that’s when the fun begins.  His first encounter is with Kaa, an enormous python, who hypnotizes him, and he’s nearly eaten until Bagheera intervenes.  In this first trial, he fails.  He’s not ready to take on Shere Khan.  This makes sense.  He needs to grow up and become a worthy opponent.  He must earn the right to confront Shere Khan and defeat him.

Jungle Book: Mowgli, the Man-Cub
Mowgli, the Man-Cub

Next, he has a run-in with Colonel Hathi, the elephant, and his marching herd, but he doesn’t fit in with them.  This is one of the themes: he’s neither a wolf nor an elephant.  He needs to find his own kind.  In the next stage of his journey, he meets another seeming accomplice, Baloo the Bear.  Baloo is an affable mammal, but once again, being a bear he’s not someone who can provide appropriate guidance to Mowgli.

Baloo winds up losing Mowgli to King Louie and his royal court of monkeys.  King Louie, a hip orangutan, wants to know how to make fire.  This is critical.  Being able to make fire and control it is what distinguishes man from the apes, and the king wants this secret knowledge.  Mowgli doesn’t have that knowledge yet, however.  Gaining that knowledge will be crucial to conquering Shere Khan, but Mowgli is still not ready.

My favorite scene in any Disney film follows as Baloo and Bagheera team up to rescue Mowgli from the apes.  It’s a wonderful, chaotic musical sequence, which leads to the ruin of an ancient temple.  Their mission successful, Mowgli thinks he and Baloo are going to pal around, but Baloo sides with Bagheera and agrees that Mowgli has to go to the Man-Village.  Mowgli escapes from the two of them and he’s on his own.

Prior to his final confrontation with Shere Khan, Mowgli has another meeting with Kaa, who comes close to swallowing him, but Mowgli manages to escape, not entirely on his own, but an improvement.  The last group of jungle animals that Mowgli attempts to fit in with are the vultures, the Beatles-looking, barbershop-quartet-singing vultures.  They haze him, but take pity on him and invite him to join them.

Before Mowgli can announce to the world that he self-identifies as a winged, carrion-eater, Shere Khan arrives.  The showdown is here, but unlike Simba, Mowgli is ready for it.  He’s run with the wolves, marched with the elephants, partied witht the apes, travelled with a panther and a bear, and hung with the vultures.  He’s ready for this challenge.

Despite Shere Khan’s ferocity, he has one weakness: his fear of fire.  What King Louie desired, what sets man apart, Mowgli’s power, is his ability to control fire.  During the chaotic battle that ensues, where the vultures, Baloo, and Mowgli combine forces, a lightning bolt sets a branch afire.  Mowgli ties the branch to Shere Khan’s tail and the frightened tiger runs away.  Mowgli has earned his victory.

The Lion King

Simba, in contrast with Mowgli, is born a future king.  He’s the son of King Mufasa and Queen Sarabi, who rule over the Pride Lands.  After his evil uncle Scar kills the king, he convinces Simba that it was his fault and that he should leave the Pride Lands and never return.

Lion King: Simba, Timon, and Pumbaa
Simba, Timon, and Pumbaa – No Worries, Man…

Here’s a great opportunity for him to prove himself.  He leaves the pride, goes out on his own, and has to learn how to survive.  There were so many possibilities.  Instead, he runs into Timon, the meerkat, and Pumbaa, the warthog, at an oasis, and his entire process of becoming an adult is reduced to a song: “Hakuna Mutata”  (“no worries” in Swahili).

No worries?  Are you kidding me?  This lion just lost his father and got kicked out of his pride.  Where do the writers have him grow up?  At an oasis?  An oasis!?!  Talk about easy living.  Where’s the struggle?  Where’s the hardship?  Where are the obstacles he must overcome before I can believe he’s capable of challenging Scar for the kingship of the Pride Lands?  Instead of gorging himself on the two prey animals, they teach him how to eat bugs!  Bugs?  Why not sip latte’s in a Brooklyn coffee shop sporting a mane-bun?  What’s next a claw-cure at a Vietnamese nail salon?

To prove how ill-equipped he is to take over the reins of power, his old girlfriend Nala comes along and attacks Timon and Pumbaa.  When Simba, the spoiled rich lion who’s been hanging out in clubs and squandering his father’s good name, attempts to defend them, she pins him.  He can’t even beat up a lioness!  That’s how lame he is!  Totally unworthy of a kingdom.  Go take another bong hit, Simba.  Listen to some more Grateful Dead.  You’re worthless.

We’re supposed to believe he can take on the wily Scar and his hyena buddies?  Not a chance.  Big disappointment.

Conclusion

The Jungle Book (the original, haven’t seen the remake) beats The Lion King hands down.  It isn’t even close.  I haven’t even touched on the music, which is also about a hundred times better.  All in all, The Jungle Book stands alone, a much better coming-of-age tale than The Lion King, and much better movie overall.

Follow Robert:

Latest posts from

65 Responses

  2. best rwanda gorilla tours
    | Reply

    Hi, Neat post. There is a problem with your web site in internet explorer, would check this… IE still is the market leader and a good portion of people will miss your fantastic writing because of this problem.

  11. telkom88 link alternatif
    | Reply

    Excellent items from you, man. I’ve keep in mind your stuff prior to and you’re just extremely wonderful. I actually like what you have obtained here, really like what you are stating and the way by which you say it. You are making it enjoyable and you still take care of to stay it smart. I can not wait to read much more from you. That is actually a terrific website.

  13. femipro
    | Reply

    I simply couldn’t depart your website before suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information a person provide to your visitors? Is going to be back steadily in order to check up on new posts

  16. prodentim
    | Reply

    Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your web site, how can i subscribe for a blog site? The account aided me a appropriate deal. I were a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided vivid transparent concept

  17. Gelatin Trick
    | Reply

    I think this internet site holds some rattling wonderful info for everyone. “Dealing with network executives is like being nibbled to death by ducks.” by Eric Sevareid.

  18. Honey Trick
    | Reply

    Simply wish to say your article is as amazing. The clearness for your post is simply cool and that i could assume you are an expert in this subject. Well along with your permission allow me to take hold of your feed to keep updated with approaching post. Thanks one million and please carry on the gratifying work.

  19. pharmacy xl hair loss
    | Reply

    Thanks , I’ve just been searching for information about this topic for ages and yours is the greatest I have discovered so far. But, what about the conclusion? Are you sure about the source?

  20. Uganda tours
    | Reply

    I am extremely impressed together with your writing skills and also with the structure in your weblog. Is that this a paid subject or did you modify it yourself? Anyway stay up the nice quality writing, it’s uncommon to peer a nice weblog like this one nowadays..

  23. gelatin trick
    | Reply

    Wonderful blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News. Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Many thanks

  29. sprunki game
    | Reply

    Great article! As a tournament player, strategy is key-whether at the poker table or composing in Sprunki Incredibox. Both demand creativity and precision. Love how it builds on Incredibox’s foundation with fresh beats and deeper expression. A real game-changer for music lovers!

  31. Ethical hacking certifications
    | Reply

    The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.

  34. vegas casino einzahlungsbonus
    | Reply

    Gerade für Poker-Fans, aber auch Spielautomaten Freunde lohnt
    sich zum Beispiel ein Abstecher nach Schenefeld im Westen Hamburgs.
    Dort ist es den Spielhallen Betreibern gesetzlich erlaubt, von 9 bis 6 Uhr zu öffnen und nicht nur von 12 Uhr bis 5 Uhr,
    wie in allen anderen Gebieten der Stadt. Das Automatencasino, das von der Spielbank Hamburg KG
    betrieben wird, befindet sich im Erdgeschoss des Hotels Graf Moltke
    und verfügt über etwas mehr als 75 Spielautomaten, die auf 370
    Quadratmeter verteilt sind. Das aufregend gestaltete Automatencasino gehört zu den modernsten in Deutschland und auch
    die Automatenauswahl ist auf dem neuesten Stand. Auch Roulette kann an elektronischen Anlagen und an Live Tischen mit Croupiers gespielt werden.
    Die Glücksspielgeschichte reicht in Österreich viele Jahrhunderte in die Vergangenheit.
    Heutzutage wirft niemand mehr Münzen in die Spielautomaten in den österreichischen Casinos.

    Dabei können die Spieler drei verschiedene Stufen, abhängig
    von den gesammelten Statuspunkten erreichen, wie
    in einem VIP-Club im Casino online. Es gibt ein sogenanntes Glücks Card
    Bonus-Programm in österreichischen Casinos. Das ist
    der höchste in Österreich verfügbare Jackpot in einem Spielcasino vor Ort.
    Grob genommen, lassen sich die Spiele in Spielautomaten und Tischspiele unterteilen.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/wunderino-casino-login-ihr-tor-zu-spannenden-spielen/

  35. fdertolmrtokev
    | Reply

    I’m very happy to read this. This is the type of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that’s at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this greatest doc.

  36. stake auszahlung nicht möglich
    | Reply

    Immerhin werden den Spielern Einsatzmittel überlassen, mit denen diese sogar echtes Geld gewinnen können. Die Casinos gehen mit diesen Bonusangeboten ein gewaltiges Risiko ein.
    Genau dieses risikolose Setzverhalten führt jedoch zur
    Ungültigkeit deines Bonus. In diesem Fall verlierst du das verbleibende Bonusgeld und würdest diesen Betrag schlicht verschenken. Anders sieht es aus, wenn der
    Casinobonus ohne einzahlen als alleiniges Angebot bereitgestellt wird.

    Der 100 % Willkommensbonus ist dabei ebenfalls mit Freispielen versehen. Wir zeigen dir, wo es denbesten Casino Echtgeld Bonus ohne Einzahlunggibt, wie du mit dem
    geschenkten Guthaben oder Freispielen dann es auch
    tatsächlich zur Auszahlung bringen kannst und worauf noch zu achten ist.
    Vielmehr bedeutet es, dass man kein Echtgeld benutzen muss, um in diesen Casinos zu
    spielen. Grundsätzlich kann man so im Casino ohne Einzahlung spielen, echtes Geld
    gewinnen, und das nach der Anmeldung direkt für seine Lieblingsspiele
    zum Wetten einsetzen. In einem No Deposit Casino kannst du um Bargeld spielen, ohne dafür vorher
    eine Einzahlung machen zu müssen. Die Spieler müssen das gewonnene Geld
    aus den Freispielen 25x mal umsetzen und können es dann erst
    auszahlen oder als Echtgeld verwenden.
    Übrigens haben wir bei Latest Casino Bonuses schon mehrere
    Auszeichnungen für besonders beispielhafte Arbeit im Bereich
    des Casino Affiliates erhalten. Viele Bonusangebote dieser Art werden in Zusammenarbeit mit Affiliate Seiten erstellt.
    Hier findest du diverse Bonusangebote, für die du dich nur in dem Casino anmelden musst.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/lapalingo-casino-cashback-ihr-weg-zu-mehr-spielguthaben/

  38. Fast withdrawal casinos Australia no KYC
    | Reply

    RocketPlay Casino will cover 10% of your net live casino losses,
    up to a whopping A$8,000 weekly. He’s lethal with cards, especially poker, and
    a go-to guy for anything casino-related. Avoid jackpots or ultra-high-volatility games unless they’re explicitly eligible.

    Getting your hands on a no deposit bonus is
    pretty simple, but there are a few steps you don’t want to
    skip. Winnings from those spins usually go into a bonus balance
    with a cap (e.g. $150 AUD) and 30x–50x wagering. To cash it out, you’ll need to meet the
    wagering requirement (often 30x–50x) and sometimes make a
    real-money deposit to unlock withdrawals. Once you
    sign up and verify your details, sometimes via SMS or email, the casino credits your account
    with either free spins or a small cash amount.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/playcroco-casino-a-comprehensive-review/

  39. latest online casinos Australia sign up
    | Reply

    Once you open the casino’s official website,
    tap the register button and enter the required information. Check our list and the awards assigned to
    each casino to pick the best one based on your needs.
    You won, mission accomplished, now it’s time to withdraw.
    Whether you’re playing a positive progression (the Paroli System) or a negative progression strategy (Martingale), you should always proceed with the utmost caution.
    Remember when I said I would give you my own gambling tips that my friends
    never want to hear about? Their common point is that their game sessions per
    bet are instant – you either win or lose.
    Australia has a booming online gambling scene, with loads of operators
    supplying Aussies with top quality games. The platform boasts an array of
    over 250 casino games, highlighting live roulette—a
    favorite among table game connoisseurs—as well as a variety of other classics.

    With an array of over 1,500 casino delights, punters are spoilt for choice, from the classic allure of
    the pokies to a smorgasbord of table games.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/ggbet-casino/

  40. Bars slot tips
    | Reply

    Table games like blackjack and baccarat might be your go-to.
    Casinonic drops a solid A$7,500 in bonus cash and gives you
    access to 700+ jackpot pokies, including high-volatility options that reward patience and timing.
    It ranks among the best Bitcoin casinos, where you get A$8,000 + 400 free spins welcome package for
    a strong start.
    These are casino rewards reserved for punters with new gambling accounts.
    Please remember that the majority of bonuses are subjected to wagering requirements.
    The most popular and widespread types are welcome bonus and first deposit
    bonus.
    However, we thought we should mention it since it will be the largest, most thrilling land-based casino in Australia.
    Hold your horses; this casino has not yet come to life. However, there’s no doubt that luxury is
    the casino’s main focus, and everything about it will make you want to straighten your back and walk
    with your head held high.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/fair-go-casino-login-guide/

  41. top casino sites Australia
    | Reply

    The top-rated Aussie casinos typically don’t charge transaction fees.
    In any case, you must have the minimum required amount in your real
    money balance to request a withdrawal. If you win while wagering real money,
    your payouts will be added to your real money balance.

    These TV-show-style games involve dice, lottery-style draws, money
    wheels, and even fishing, with bonus rounds, multipliers, and unlimited seating
    built in. A controlled dice mechanism ensures fairness, and beginner-friendly tutorials built into some games help new players quickly learn the basics.
    Below is a breakdown of the most popular live casino games in Australia, along with our top
    recommendations for each category. RNG games generate instant outcomes, making them ideal for players who prefer fast-paced gameplay.

    You shouldn’t settle for Australian online
    casino sites that need 3 days to approve a payout request.

    Wagering requirements must be within industry limits, the bonuses should be accessible to all
    players, and the expiry dates should be reasonable. The three things these
    games have in common are that their RTP is very high (usually 98%+), the gameplay is quick, and they all offer a different type of
    gameplay. This adds yet another element to playing casino games, and I’m
    all in for this one.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/vip-slots-casino-no-deposit-bonus-codes/

  53. banca multifuncional
    | Reply

    Hi, Neat post. There is a problem with your web site in internet explorer, would test this… IE still is the market leader and a big portion of people will miss your magnificent writing because of this problem.

  54. apartamentos de alquiler por dias
    | Reply

    I do enjoy the manner in which you have presented this particular matter and it does indeed present us some fodder for consideration. On the other hand, coming from what precisely I have observed, I basically wish as the actual responses stack on that folks remain on point and not start upon a soap box involving the news du jour. Still, thank you for this outstanding point and while I can not really concur with the idea in totality, I regard the standpoint.

  55. José Ignacio Real estate
    | Reply

    Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you really know what you’re talking about! Bookmarked. Please also visit my web site =). We could have a link exchange arrangement between us!

  57. jililive
    | Reply

    Roulette’s randomness is fascinating – the math really does hold up over time! Seeing platforms like jililive login prioritize a smooth user experience & security is great for enjoying those odds. Quick registration is a plus too!

  60. tlover tonet
    | Reply

    Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing.

  61. watch shemale hentai videos
    | Reply

    Свежие xxx-платформы предлагают инновационный
    контент для развлечений для взрослых.
    Откройте для себя гарантированные порнохабы для современного опыта.

    Here is my web blog watch shemale hentai videos

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.